Marc Wildemeersch, George Orwell’s Commander in Spain: The Enigma of Georges Kopp, Thames River Press, 2013; pp. 10+134; fully illustrated.

This valuable monograph originated in Marc Wildemeersch’s De man die Belg wilde worden. Georges Kopp, commandant van George Orwell, published in the Netherlands in 2010. Now, most welcomingly, it is available in English. By and large the translation follows the Dutch original but its notes have been amplified and two chapters, four and five, have been inverted. Because I have been privileged to contribute a short Epilogue to the English edition I am in danger of merely repeating myself in introducing this study to prospective readers and that I hope to avoid.

When we try to understand the personalities, attributes, and actions of those we know personally or about whom we write we quite often come across puzzles of action or personality that we have difficulty in resolving. Orwell himself and a number of those whom he knew or with whom he corresponded present us with a number of such problems. Kopp is not singular in this respect but working out who he really was and how Orwell understood him is important both for Kopp, for Orwell, and, most sensitively, for his first wife, Eileen.

Perhaps I might take another man who has an even more shadowy relationship with Orwell to illustrate this problem. I began my working life in 1942 in the cutting rooms of the Crown Film Unit. Although we were concerned with actualité the small group of teenagers who worked there were fascinated by the work of Len Lye, an innovator in film and sculpture. We would play on the Moviolas not only copies of his short films – many painted in colour directly on to film stock – but also rejected lengths of film. None of us were familiar with Lye’s avant garde techniques and yet we were fascinated by what we saw. Could Orwell have been as interested as were we? Orwell seems not to have had a natural sympathy for documentary film if one goes by his few reviews of such films. He never mentions either of two of the most significant documentary films of the mid 1930s, two films which one would think would have attracted his attention and about which he might have had much to say – Housing Problems, 1935, and Enough to Eat?, 1936, both directed by Edgar Anstey, and both, ironically, sponsored by the gas industry. If you have never seen Housing Problems look at it with the illustrations of The Road to Wigan Pier before you and the text of that book in mind. One of the puzzles I was unable to resolve when assembling the Complete Works was what seems to be a letter from Len Lye to Orwell about the time that Lye made The Birth of the Robot, 1936. What had Lye and Orwell in common? (Incidentally, you can see on the internet all seven minutes of The Birth of the Robot, advertising a Shell-Mes lubricating oil, in glorious Gasparcolor and complete with Gustav Holst’s music.)

When I was editing the Complete Works I was nearly as puzzled by Georges Kopp as by Len Lye. Since then much fascinating information has been dug out, first by Bert Govaerts (reproduced in The Lost Orwell, the supplementary volume to the Complete Works), and now, by Marc Wildemeersch who enlarges significantly on Govaerts’s account in this most useful and intriguing biography. Extracts from the autobiography of David Crook (whom Gordon Bowker refers to in his biography) are usefully included. The aptly-named Crook was recruited to spy on Orwell and Kopp, even going so far as to observe Kopp when in prison with him. (Crook would later move to China and was imprisoned from 1967 to 1973 during the Chinese Cultural Revolution; he died in 1990.)

We are also introduced to even more shadowy figures such as Philippe Keun, and especially those in Kopp’s espionage ring near Marseille – R.O Stokes (who Kopp knew in Belgium and for whom he seems later to have worked briefly in London), Marc Jottard, André Jouve, Julien Paul (alias Polo), and a mysterious Mr Lance who, although confessing that Kopp ‘might be [in London] with the highest motives . . . might be up to no good’. The final chapter, sadly entitled ‘Downhill’ is particularly interesting. And there are amusing sidelights. Thus, Mr Wildemeersch mentions on p. 13 how Noam Chomsky, when showing how Stalinists twisted history, gets himself in a twist when describing Kopp as ‘a Trotskyist general’, something not even our Georges claimed.

As someone who has no facility in writing in any other language than English I am reluctant to suggest that there are slight infelicities in the English of this translation (should ‘ever’ on p.7, line 9 be ‘never’?) but far from marring the telling of this fascinating story they add to its immediacy and authenticity. I do regret, however, that there is no index. Nevertheless, this is an indispensable book for all interested in Orwell and, indeed, the machinations of espionage rings in World War II. How could it be otherwise when it features not only George Kopp but also Anthony Blunt! Would that someone could unravel the Orwell-Len Lye relationship as effectively.

Peter Davison

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Marc Wildemeersch, George Orwell’s Commander in Spain: The Enigma of Georges Kopp, Thames River Press, 2013; pp. 10+134; fully illustrated.

  1. Page 242 of “Len Lye: A Biography” has an exchange of correspondence between Lye and Orwell. Lye wrote to GO in June 1949 saying that he felt Animal Farm would make “an excellent basis for a film about individualism” and despite his illness Orwell replied that “of course I remember you” and goes on to give his approval for Lye’s involvement in such a project. Do we know if anything resulted from this correspondence? Presumably not as there isnt a Lye film of Animal Farm I assume?

    Like

  2. I am most grateful to David Ford for the information from Len Lye’s biography which, I regret to say I did not know. There is not so far as I know a Len Lye film of “Animal Farm” – would there were! And I have not come across Orwell’s letter to Len Lye of June 1949. It all goes to show what I have always known – there is too much I don’t know. Thank you. Peter Davison

    Like

  3. I am delighted to report that the launch of Orwell’s Commander in Spain, The enigma of Georges Kopp has been a great success. We had 3 events at good bookshops. They were Bookmarks Bookshop, 1 Bloomsbury St and Scarthin Books in Cromford, Derbyshire and last night at Saltaire Bookshop in Yorkshire (not to be be confused with the one in Salts Mill).
    Each night the location was full to overflowing and Marc had lots of very different questions and interesting discussions arose.
    These excellent bookshops, if they are in striking distance are really great places to buy books. An Orwell Society member owns Saltaire and another is part of the team at Scarthin.
    Marc and his wife Ellen returned to Belgium today.

    Like

    • Dear Sir,
      I would like send this mail to Marc Wildemeersch but have not been able to get an address. Maybe you could further it to him.
      Thank you

      Dear Sir,
      I read, with great pleasure, your book on Georges Kopp. I would like to write a review of it for a french weekly.
      On page 68 you speak of a “Petite essay d’analyse marxiste des evénements d’Espagne 1936-1939”.
      Could you send me a copy of this “Petit essay”, in English or French, or tell me where I can find it ?
      I would be happy to be of service to you for any book, contact or service you could need in Paris, where I live. My mail is vergajofra@aol.com and my web-site is http://www.franciscovergara.com
      Thank you kindly
      Francisco Vergara

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s